There is something that I've been wanting to speak out about for years now, and recently attending a seminar at Cornerstone called "Love is an Orientation" has helped me feel empowered to articulate the attitude that I have about Christianity and homosexuality. I feel that the principles that I'm going to talk about are are Biblical, loving, honest, and long overdue to be lived out by those who claim to follow Christ. As someone who has had ample life experience in both the Christian church and the gay community, and as someone who has felt the temptation of same-sex attraction myself, I want to address and rebuke the Church for its overall treatment of this particular enclave of our Father's beloved creation.
Christians, let me start with this: I know you are aware of the gay community's aversion to you. I know you know that they hold much against you. Now let me tell you what they DON'T hold against you. The gay community does not hold against you your right to the belief that homosexuality is a sin according to the Scriptural principles of your faith, according to your God. They do not hold against you your right not to approve of a homosexual lifestyle according to those beliefs. But the keyword there is your. Your God. Your faith. Your beliefs. The gay community is perfectly fine with agreeing to disagree. The problem comes in when you demand that a gay person operate by the moral code of a God they don't believe in or don't care about. You cannot in sound logic expect them to do that any more than a Muslim could expect you to eat only halal meat because it is prescribed in the Quran.
And why, do you think, would the gay community not believe in or not care about our Christian God? How much of it has to do with the actual principles that are found in a close, well-informed reading of the Bible, and how much of it has to do with the vastly prejudiced and very often despicable behavior of so-called Christians towards themselves and their loved ones? If we say that the Bible designates homosexuality as a sin, let's go ahead and take a look and just a few of the ways in which we deal with other sins according to Scripture and see if they line up with how we treat homosexuality:
1. Temptation vs. Action - If a brother confides in us that he had the urge to shoplift while he was waiting in line at the grocery store but resisted it and paid for all his items instead, what do we do? We pat him on the back and thank God that he defeated his temptation. If a sister confides in us that she is struggling with homosexual desires but has not acted on them, what do we do? How do we view her? As someone who has triumphed over temptation, or as someone who is already tainted, sinful, and an outsider merely from the thoughts that are in her head?
Hebrews tells us that we do not have a God who is unable to identify with us, but "one who has been tempted in every way, just as we are—yet was without sin." There is a clear separation here between the temptation of sin and the sin itself. If the Scripture says that Jesus was tempted "in every way," would that not also include lust? Instead of sinking immediately into shame and defeatism when temptation of any kind strikes, we are instructed to "approach the throne of grace with confidence, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help us in our time of need."
I wonder how many gay folks have felt that they have found mercy and grace to help in their time of need at the doors of the Church.
2. Behavior over Relationship: When we talk to a straight non-Christian about Jesus, what is the biggest point we hope to emphasize? This could probably be a whole entry in and of itself, but for the time being let's assume that we all have a correct understand of the Gospel and would want the person to understand that God loves them and wants so desperate to commune with them that He sent his own Son, and extension of his own Being, to sacrifice himself in order to bridge the gap between God's heart and theirs. In comparison, what is the biggest point we always end up emphasizing when we talk to a gay non-Christian? Homosexuality is a sin and you're going to hell if you keep it up. Do we even understand how insulting that is? Do we even get it? The straight Gospel message says "You matter. You are of value, so much so that the Creator of the universe is desperately in love with you." The gay Gospel message says "Your entire personhood is defined by this one single characteristic, and God despises it. And since you and your homosexuality are inseparable, God despises you."
So what exactly does God think about these two alternate Gospels? "You, therefore, have no excuse, you who pass judgment on someone else, for at whatever point you judge the other, you are condemning yourself, because you who pass judgment do the same things. Now we know that God's judgment against those who do such things is based on truth. So when you, a mere man, pass judgment on them and yet do the same things, do you think you will escape God's judgment? Or do you show contempt for the riches of his kindness, tolerance and patience, not realizing that God's kindness leads you toward repentance?" - Romans 2:1-5
When a gay person walks away from a conversation with you, do they feel God's kindness or your judgment?
3. Get It Right Or Get The F&%$ Out: So you were perfect by the time you gave your life to Christ, right? You were a spotless lamb before the Lord, already cleansed of every sin, bad habit, and incorrect worldview and really just looking for some heavenly companionship rather than any sort of salvation. Your perspective of God and the world has never wavered because you've never spiritually matured or grown in any way (already being perfect and all).
Wait...that's not the case? You're telling me you came to Jesus full of sin, hurt, and brokenness, and the promise of healing the gaping wound in your heart is what drew you to Him in the first place? And you mean to tell me that healing hasn't happened overnight? That in fact, it's still in the process of happening, and that there are sins that you deal with on a regular basis, over and over again, even when you think you've finally gotten free of them?
You're telling me that your brothers and sisters in Christ act like just that--brothers and sisters? That they love you unconditionally just as your heavenly Father loves you, and they deal patiently and mercifully with your every weakness, fault, and bout of utter stupidity because they too are just as weak and stupid? Oh really. That's very interesting. Then why exactly are we so eager to kick a gay man out of our church the moment he shows up with his boyfriend when we have no problem whatsoever bearing with the Sunday School teacher's gossip problem, the megachurch preacher's lust for riches, or our own [straight] secret porn addiction?
Again, God's command to us is clear through humble admission of Paul: "Not that I have already obtained all this, or have already been made perfect, but I press on to take hold of that for which Christ Jesus took hold of me...All of us who are mature should take such a view of things. And if on some point you think differently, that too God will make clear to you."
__________________________________
I have, at least to some extent, seen the view from both sides of this fence, and I firmly believe that there is no group of people in the world today to whom the message of Jesus Christ has been more grossly perverted than the gay community, and that is a tragedy that falls squarely on the shoulders of us, the messengers.
Why oh why do we feel that the proper and necessary way to show a gay person that we disapprove of homosexuality is to withhold love from them? Is that how Jesus showed his disapproval of our sin to us? Or did he lay down His very life for us to demonstrate His love?
Woe to us. We ought to be ashamed.
I know many Christians would argue that they do not talk to/associate with/welcome/hang out with gay people for fear that their actions might possibly get misinterpreted as approval of homosexuality. To that, I say: Take that zeal for righteousness and clean your own house with it first. Keep your integrity, leave the judging to God Almighty, and do the one simple thing your Lord and Savior commands you time and time again to do: LOVE.